Which image?

Every model renders the same brief, and a vision judge picks one image without knowing which model routing chose.

Does routing make better images?

All 5 models rendered each of 10 briefs, and a judge blind to routing picked one image. It was the routed model's on 7 of 10, the default's on 2, against 2 by chance. Scored alone out of 100, the routed image came top on 4 of 10 and the default on 3. Every brief is below.

Lifestyle shot of a woman jogging at sunrise wearing our new running shoes, the shoes should be the focus
Photoreal · 95%
Typecast's pickz-imagebest of 5
Overall score
69
Brief
69
Style
90
Craft
49
Defaultqwen-2.1
Overall score
61
Brief
53
Style
78
Craft
51

Judge's pick: the routed model (z-image). Highest overall score: krea2.

All 5 models, same prompt and seed. Outlined: the judge's pick. Click any image to enlarge.

z-image 69
krea2 74
qwen-2.1 61
anima 49
z-image-turbo 66
Hyperreal 3D render of a sneaker bursting into colorful particles, dark background, for a sportswear ad
Product · 47% · show top two
Typecast's pickkrea2best of 5
Overall score
76
Brief
94
Style
94
Craft
41
Defaultqwen-2.1
Overall score
81
Brief
91
Style
93
Craft
60

Judge's pick: the routed model (krea2). Highest overall score: qwen-2.1.

Same judge, other job: put the brand's palette, logo and tone in the question, and it picks the image that follows them.

All 5 models, same prompt and seed. Outlined: the judge's pick. Click any image to enlarge.

z-image 67
krea2 76
qwen-2.1 81
anima 71
z-image-turbo 65
need like 4 quick versions of a burger photo for the menu, doesnt have to be perfect its for a pitch tmrw
Fast draft · 96%
Typecast's pickz-image-turbobest of 5
Overall score
68
Brief
91
Style
77
Craft
37
Defaultqwen-2.1
Overall score
63
Brief
67
Style
68
Craft
54

Judge's pick: the routed model (z-image-turbo).

Same judge, other job: a batch of quick variants gets one pick instead of a person comparing them by eye.

All 5 models, same prompt and seed. Outlined: the judge's pick. Click any image to enlarge.

z-image 59
krea2 58
qwen-2.1 63
anima 48
z-image-turbo 68
busy tokyo crosswalk at night from above, long exposure, realistic
Photoreal · 98%
Typecast's pickz-imagebest of 5
Overall score
73
Brief
92
Style
84
Craft
43
Defaultqwen-2.1
Overall score
66
Brief
63
Style
74
Craft
60

Judge's pick: the routed model (z-image).

All 5 models, same prompt and seed. Outlined: the judge's pick. Click any image to enlarge.

z-image 73
krea2 69
qwen-2.1 66
anima 29
z-image-turbo 72
Logo for a bakery called 'Crumb & Co', wordmark, warm and handmade
Typography · 100%
Typecast's pick, also the defaultqwen-2.1best of 5
Overall score
94
Brief
96
Style
95
Craft
86
Text
99
Runner-upkrea2
Overall score
89
Brief
92
Style
88
Craft
77
Text
99

Judge's pick: the routed model (qwen-2.1).

Same judge, other job: ask which image spells the headline as written and keeps it legible.

All 5 models, same prompt and seed. Outlined: the judge's pick. Click any image to enlarge.

z-image 62
krea2 89
qwen-2.1 94
anima 52
z-image-turbo 63
headphones. matte black. floating. gradient bg. premium feel
Product · 93%
Typecast's pickkrea2best of 5
Overall score
74
Brief
89
Style
89
Craft
45
Defaultqwen-2.1
Overall score
69
Brief
82
Style
81
Craft
45

Judge's pick: the routed model (krea2). A split call: most orderings of the images disagreed.

All 5 models, same prompt and seed. Outlined: the judge's pick. Click any image to enlarge.

z-image 73
krea2 74
qwen-2.1 69
anima 41
z-image-turbo 64
low res is fine, just want to see if a purple vs orange palette works for the packaging
Fast draft · 68% · show top two
Typecast's pickz-image-turbobest of 5
Overall score
77
Brief
93
Style
86
Craft
52
Defaultqwen-2.1
Overall score
72
Brief
94
Style
84
Craft
40

Judge's pick: the routed model (z-image-turbo). A split call: most orderings of the images disagreed. Highest overall score: z-image.

All 5 models, same prompt and seed. Outlined: the judge's pick. Click any image to enlarge.

z-image 80
krea2 77
qwen-2.1 72
anima 79
z-image-turbo 77
Perfume bottle on black marble, the brand name 'NOIR' engraved on the glass must be clearly readable
Typography · 99%
Typecast's pick, also the defaultqwen-2.1
Overall score
71
Brief
48
Style
73
Craft
70
Text
91
Judge's pickkrea2best of 5
Overall score
87
Brief
91
Style
94
Craft
65
Text
97

Routing missed. Judge's pick: krea2, neither the routed nor the default model.

All 5 models, same prompt and seed. Outlined: the judge's pick. Click any image to enlarge.

z-image 86
krea2 87
qwen-2.1 71
anima 61
z-image-turbo 78
isometric illustration of a tiny city block with cafes and trees, soft pastel palette
Illustration · 100%
Typecast's pickanima
Overall score
59
Brief
71
Style
64
Craft
40
Defaultqwen-2.1
Overall score
79
Brief
94
Style
93
Craft
49

Routing missed. Judge's pick: krea2, neither the routed nor the default model.

Same judge, other job: pick the storyboard frame worth turning into video before paying for the render.

All 5 models, same prompt and seed. Outlined: the judge's pick. Click any image to enlarge.

z-image 69
krea2 82
qwen-2.1 79
anima 59
z-image-turbo 75
editorial illustration for an article about burnout, person melting into a desk chair, muted colors, conceptual
Illustration · 100%
Typecast's pickanima
Overall score
50
Brief
61
Style
45
Craft
43
Defaultqwen-2.1best of 5
Overall score
77
Brief
92
Style
93
Craft
45

Routing missed. Judge's pick: qwen-2.1, the default model.

All 5 models, same prompt and seed. Outlined: the judge's pick. Click any image to enlarge.

z-image 61
krea2 64
qwen-2.1 77
anima 50
z-image-turbo 59

A small, early sample: 10 briefs that routing was tuned on, judged by a model (Jev reading the images in every order), not yet checked against people. The other jobs noted on some briefs aren't measured at all. The lineup is open-weight models run locally, standing in for a real product's roster.